Generate “Net New” Net Interest Margin (NIM): Why Canadian Credit Unions Should Consider A Loan Origination Solution to Leverage the Mortgage Broker Channel

by | Aug 12, 2024

Doxim’s Loan Origination Solution presents the most cost-effective expansion into the broker channel market and “net new” net interest margin (NIM) for credit unions

The Canadian housing market continues to evolve in 2024, with notable trends including sustained high interest rates, a gradual increase in housing supply, and ongoing affordability challenges in major urban centers. Amidst these macro trends, the mortgage landscape is shifting significantly, with the broker channel playing an increasingly pivotal role. As of 2024, it’s estimated that mortgage brokers originate approximately 40% of all mortgages in Canada, up from 30% just a few years ago.   

In this analysis, we’ll explore the current state of the market, the business case for entering the broker channel, and potential financial benefits for credit unions. We will also explore why Doxim’s loan origination solution presents the most cost-effective expansion into the broker channel market for credit unions. 

Why Doxim LOS presents the most cost-effective expansion into the broker channel market and net new net interest margin (NNNIM) for credit unions.

Current State of the Canadian Mortgage Market: A Primer  

We believe the time for credit unions to build the mortgage broker business is now, due to the following factors:

Market Size and Growth

As of 2024, the Canadian mortgage market continues to be a significant component of the country’s financial landscape.

The total value of residential mortgage credit outstanding has reached approximately $2.1 trillion, representing a YoY growth of 3.5%.

Market Share Distribution

The mortgage market in Canada is dominated by the “Big Six” banks, which collectively hold about 70% of the market share.

Credit unions currently account for approximately 14% of the market, while other financial institutions and alternative lenders make up the remaining 16%.

Broker Channel Growth

The broker channel has seen significant growth in recent years.

Mortgage brokers now originate about 40% of all mortgages in Canada, up from 30% a few years ago. 3

Consumer Behavior Shifts

Recent survevs indicate that

57% of first-time homebuyers are now using mortgage brokers, up from 43% five years ago.

The Business Case

The Canadian mortgage market is a significant opportunity for credit unions. With outstanding mortgage credit reaching $2.08 trillion as of December 2023 (Bank of Canada), and the broker channel holding a 40% market share, credit unions can tap into a new customer base without extensive branch expansion. 

Entering the broker channel can diversify revenue streams and reduce reliance on traditional banking products. This diversification mitigates risks associated with market fluctuations and changing consumer preferences. Credit unions often offer more competitive rates and personalized service than big banks, with mortgage rates averaging 0.25% lower (CMHC), First-Time Homebuyer Survey 2024. Leveraging these strengths can help credit unions gain market share and establish a strong presence in this space.

Credit Unions that place a significant emphasis on broker relationships, cross-selling, and bundled product offerings may see 25% to 30% of new deposit accounts driven through the broker channel. Credit unions often provide brokers with strong incentives to bring in deposit products along with mortgage clients.

Developing the business case and ROI for credit unions broker channel entry is based on six building blocks

To illustrate the potential financial impact, let’s create a simplified model for a mid-sized credit union entering the broker channel: 

The only cost drivers for an entry into broker market for credit unions are minimal tech investment into Doxim LOS and marketing initiatives.

Business case building blocks:

Net Return
=
Net Interest Margin from New Broker Mortgages
x
Average Mortgage Size
x
Cross-Selling Revenue
Investment
=
Technology Investment in Doxim LOS
+
Broker Marketing and relationship building
+
Compliance and Risk Management

Key Assumptions:

  • Credit union’s current mortgage portfolio: $500 million
  • Annual mortgage origination target through broker channel: Year 1: $50 million, Year 2: $100 million, Year 3: $150 million
  • Average mortgage size: $490,000
  • Net interest margin: 1.8%
  • Deposits growth from new accounts and mortgage transfers. This also leads to an improved liquidity position and a reduction in cost of funding for a CU

This simplified model demonstrates that entering the broker channel could be financially viable for credit unions, with a relatively quick payback period on the initial investment.

Strategy for Implementation:

a) LOS and POS broker integration: Doxim has implemented the most robust broker integration into the Doxim Loan origination system which enables this new line of business.
b) Partnerships: Establish relationships with key mortgage broker networks and individual brokers. Consider offering exclusive products or rates to incentivize partnerships.
c) Training and Education: Invest in training programs for credit union staff to understand the nuances of working with mortgage brokers and managing broker-originated mortgages.
d) Competitive Product Offering: Develop a suite of mortgage products tailored for the broker channel, focusing on competitive rates and flexible terms to attract business.
e) Marketing and Branding: Create a targeted marketing campaign to raise awareness among brokers about the credit union’s entry into this space and its unique value proposition. We will also be sharing all marketing and business development strategies in an upcoming companion piece “Implementing a Broker Channel Strategy: A Practical Guide for Canadian Credit Unions.”

Doxim’s Loan Origination Solution (LOS) and How Credit Unions Benefit

Doxim’s Loan Origination (LOS) and its new Filogix integration empower credit unions to efficiently enter the mortgage broker channel and driving potential net new-NIM growth. Key benefits for credit unions are:

  • Easy, turn-key access to the broker channel POS network using Doxim’s LOS
  • On-boarding of additional customers and new revenue streams
  • Smooth integration of data from broker channel POS submission to Doxim LOS (no manual entry of data for financial institutions)
  • Geographic distribution limits (e.g., only receiving deals from the province(s) of choice)

Credit Unions and the Broker Channel: A Promising Path for Diversification

Entering the broker channel presents a significant opportunity for Canadian credit unions to expand their mortgage business, diversify revenue streams, and enhance their market presence. While there are challenges to overcome, including technology investments and establishing broker relationships, the potential benefits make this a compelling strategic move.

For a detailed guide on how to implement this strategy, including insights on loan origination software, broker relationship development, and marketing strategies, please refer to Doxim’s upcoming companion piece: “Implementing a Broker Channel Strategy: A Practical Guide for Canadian Credit Unions.” 

As with any major strategic initiative, it’s crucial for credit unions to conduct thorough market research, assess their individual circumstances, and carefully consider the risks and rewards before making the leap into the broker channel space. However, for those willing to invest the time and resources, the broker channel offers a promising path for growth and diversification in the Canadian mortgage market and Doxim LOS presents the most cost-effective path to enabling a new additional revenue stream. 

Our Bloggers

Erin Romo headshot
Gum Fa Ng

CCM Strategy

James Hall headshot
James Hall

CCM in Europe

Jason Pothen headshot
Jason Pothen

CCM in Utilities, Healthcare, and Consumer Finance

Josh Noble headshot
Josh Noble

CCM for Banks and Credit Unions

Bill Cullen headshot
Bill Cullen

CCM in Insurance

Curly Lippa headshot
Curly Lippa

CCM in Wealth Management

Shah javed headshot
Shah Javed

CEM Product Strategy

Guest Bloggers

Keypoint Intelligence logo
Keypoint Intelligence

CCM Industry Experts

Shah Javed
Vice President, Product – CEM at Doxim
Shah joined Doxim in 2019 and is the head of strategy and product management for Doxim's Customer Engagement Management (CEM) platform.
Shah has held product, management consulting and executive roles while launching and scaling products in insurance, financial services and healthcare companies.
Shah holds a MBA with specializations in information systems strategy/ leadership and innovation from the Edinburgh Napier School of Business, and most recently completed an executive program in strategic innovation from the Said School of Business at the University of Oxford.

Connect with me
Schedule My Demo
Skip to form